American Idol - Girls Night March 4

The performances were just alright for me. Like the guys, there weren’t any real breakout performances in my mind. Below is my take on the performances. The scores I attached are my impression immediately after hearing their individual songs. My notes about the songs and scores were written prior to hearing any judge’s feedback. Graded on a scale from 1 to 10 with 1 being the lowest.

Asia’h - 8 - Tough to do a Whitney song but she did a good job and did her own thing with it instead of try to sing it like Whitney. Good call.

Kady - 7 - Not bad. A couple of pitch problems and had to slide up to some notes to finally get it.

Amanda - 7 - Her embarrassing story was she burned down a pool? That’s not embarrassing, that’s arsony. Wow, she sang in key this week. Not a good ending to the song though.

Carly - 9 - Great job. Best of the night so far. Probably the most polished of the girls.

Kristy - 8 - Wasn’t a fan of the twang. Don’t think the song needed it. Vocally she did a good job until the end run.

Ramiele - 7 - Eh. Good voice but didn’t do a great job with the song. I think she had a little rhythm problem. Made it difficult for me to get what she was trying to do.

Brooke - 7 - Some pitchy moments. Might be in trouble this week. I disagree with the judges. She should have used the band more.

Syesha - 8 - Nice. No real bad notes to speak of. Was a little slow for me but a solid performance.

A few girls are potentially in trouble this week as I see it. But, my track record wasn’t the greatest last week so I could be way off. I think Kady and Brook are going home.

Posted by: Vonski | 03-05-2008 | 10:03 PM
Posted in: Entertainment