American Idol - Guys Night March 4th

So the guys didn’t bring the heat tonight. Below is my take on the performances. The scores I attached are my impression immediately after hearing their individual songs. My notes about the songs and scores were written prior to hearing any judge’s feedback. Graded on a scale from 1 to 10 with 1 being the lowest.

Luke - 5 - I just KNEW he was going to sing a Wham song. Bummer.

David A - 8 - Not as good as last week. A couple of flat notes but good for the most part.

Danny - 7 - Had a few problems early on. Best song choice so far.

David H - 8 - Some pitch problems, too but probably the most consistent of all the guys, IMO.

Michael - 8 - Good job. Good song choice. Uh Randy, Michael Hutchence? It was Simple Minds. Thought you were a music guy.

David C - 8 - I like the tone to his voice. Gutsy singing a Lionel Ritchie song and mixing it up. Kinda worked.

Jason - 6 - I love the Leonard Cohen song but he sang it with too much uncertainty. There was not enough power in his voice so he couldn’t push the notes well. I have no idea what the judges heard. I thought it was awful. The only reason Simon liked it is, he actually knew the song for a change.

Chikezie - 7 - A bit sharp at times. I like the song but he didn’t do a great job with it. Too bad, I was liking this guy until tonight.

There weren’t any stand out performances in my mind. The closest was probably David Cook with his “Hello” joint. Hmm… If they’re getting rid of 2 guys this week, I’d have to pick Luke and Chikezie as the ones going home.

Posted by: Vonski | 03-04-2008 | 10:03 PM
Posted in: Entertainment